Who is the Hindi film hero with the maximum number of popular songs picturized on him? Most would say ‘Dev Anand’ and I would agree.

Who’s next? Who’s second best? By my reckoning the name that comes after Dev Anand is ‘Rajesh Khanna’. I’m aware that there’s an upsurge of interest in Kaka songs after he passed away, but between 1969 and 1974 he sang an incredibly large number of popular songs.

And who’s third? Now this is getting interesting! While Shammi Kapoor might win more votes … and many will therefore disagree with my choice … I’m picking ‘Rajendra Kumar’. As ‘Jubilee Kumar’ he met enormous success in the 1960s; unfortunately the Kaka wave buried this success.

In fact let us start the second part of this series with Rajendra Kumar. So who is the playback singer who qualifies best to be Rajendra Kumar’s ‘paired associate’? Easy, very easy. Mohammed Rafi! While there was a bit of Mukesh at the beginning (tum roothi raho from Aas Ka Panchhi) and the end (mere pyaar bhi tu hai from Saathi and dheere dheere bol from Gora Aur Kala) of his career, it was really Rafi all the way.

Where do we start with Rajendra Kumar-Rafi? Husn wale tera jawab nahi from Gharana would be a delightful opening; in fact teri pyari pyari surat from Sasural might win even more points. Mere mehboob tujhe might today seem a little laboured but it created a sensation when the film was released. Then there was the soulful and gut-wrenching yaad na jaaye from Dil Ek Mandir, and ye mera prem patra from Sangam with a lovely opening passage that we rarely hear.

This melodious musical journey would continue with tum kamseen ho from Aaye Milan Ki Bela, the melodious trio of ae phoolon ki rani, chhalke teri aankhon se and ae nargise mastaana from Arzoo, kaun hai jo sapnon mein aaya from Jhuk Gaya Aasman. However the Rajendra Kumar-Rafi song that became the most popular was this:

While Rafi was unmistakably Rajendra Kumar’s voice things are not so simple with Sunil Dutt. To be sure Rafi has sung some memorable songs for Sunil Dutt: na main bhagwan hoon from Mother India, yeh waadiyan yeh fizayein from Aaj Aur Kal and aap ke pehlu mein aa kar from Mera Saaya. There were also some truly pleasing duets with three of Hindi cinema’s most beautiful ladies: chand sa mukhda with Asha (singing for Madhubala) in Insaan Jaag Utha, chand jane kahaan kho gaya with Lata (singing for Meena Kumari) in Main Chup Rahungi, and yeh khamoshiyaan with Asha now singing for the lovely Leela Naidu in Yeh Raaste Hain Pyar Ke.

But Sunil Dutt sang in Talat Mehmood’s voice for some of Salil Chowdhury’s finest compositions: aha rim jhim ke from Usne Kaha Tha, aansoon samajh ke and itna na mujhse pyar badha from Chhaya … and, above all, that superlative S D Burman composition: jalte hain jiske liye from Sujata.  Then there was Mukesh with chhodo kal ki baatein from Hum Hindustani and sawan ka mahina in Milan, and even a bit of Kishore Kumar with kehna hai in Padosan.

Surprisingly, that’s not all. Some of Sunil Dutt’s best songs have been sung by Mahendra Kumar with Ravi’s music. Tum agar saath dena ka and kisi pathhar ki murat se from Hamraaz, aap aaye to from Gumrah … and of course that other song from Gumrah which is my best pick for Sunil Dutt and Mahendra Kapoor:

As someone with a success span of more than two full decades Dharmendra has had a lot of popular songs picturized on him. I personally favour the ‘softer’ songs picturized on him in the 1960s when he wasn’t yet ‘Garam Dharam’. Listen to Madan Mohan’s yehi hai tamanna from Aap Ki Parchhaiyan, O P Nayyar’s aap ke haseen rukh from Baharen Phir Bhi Aayengi, Sonik-Omi’s kaliyon ne ghunghat khole from Dil Ne Phir Yaad Kiya, Madan Mohan again with ek haseen shaam ko from Dulhan Ek Raat Ki or Hemant Kumar’s ya dil ki suno from Anupama. I also like Laxmikant-Pyarelal’s chalkaye jaam and hui shaam unka from Mere Hamdam Mere Dost.

Dharmendra continued his singing ways in the 1970s but the playback voice was now increasingly Kishore Kumar. We now had LP’s jaani o jaani from Raja Jani, Kalyanji-Anandji’s pal pal dil ke paas from Blackmail, the hugely popular arey rafta rafta from Kahani Kismat Ki, LP’s kisi shaayar ki ghazal from Dream Girl and R D Burman’s ham bewafa hargiz na they from Shalimar.

However the old Punjabi connection between Dharmendra, Rafi and Pyarelal ensured that Rafi reappeared even in his dismal 1970s. There was aaj mausam bada beimaan hai from Loafer, o meri mehbooba from Dharamveer, and this racy number from Pratigya that captures the quintessential Rafi-Dharam bond.

For someone who has been around for so long Shashi Kapoor doesn’t have as many popular songs as one might expect. In particular, Shashi Kapoor sang very few solo hits. His early hits with Rafi included three Kalyanji-Anandji compositions: pardesiyon se na from Jab Jab Phool Khile, the slightly boisterous nain mila kar chain churana from Aamne Saamne, and the duet bekhudi mein sanam from Hasina Maan Jayegi. There was also a pleasing Shankar-Jaikishan composition likhe jo khat tujhe from Kanyadaan.

As we entered the 1970s, Kishore Kumar began to start replacing Rafi as Shashi Kapoor’s playback singer, although the immensely successful tum bin jaoon kahaan from Pyar Ka Mausam is picturized on Shashi in Rafi’s voice. Then followed S D Burman’s Sharmilee which was Shashi Kapoor’s biggest musical hit with khilte hain gul yahan and kaise kahen hum being Kishore Kumar’s two best solos. R D Burman’s Aa Gale Lag Jaa also had some lovely music including tera mujhse hai pehle ka nata koi. But my pick for the best Shashi-Kishore combo would be this Ravindra Jain song from Chor Machaye Shor:

We finally come to Hindi cinema’s biggest superstar: Amitabh Bachchan. In his Babu Moshai days it seemed scarcely possible that the intense actor would burst into song. Eventually Amitabh did start singing, allowing a wisp of a smile to overtake his grave demeanour as Kishore Kumar sang a beautiful R D Burman composition, kya jano main hoon kaun, for him in Bandhe Haath. Then, as a singer in Abhimaan, Amitabh discovered a bit of freedom to prance around on stage with meet na mila re manka; although he might have preferred a cordless microphone. Amitabh’s break-free moment, to Mehmood’s great surprise, came as he sang dekha na hai re soncha na in Bombay To Goa.

Now more comfortable singing on screen, Amitabh — always in Kishore Kumar’s voice — sang three lovely solos: aadmi jo kehto hai in Majboor, badi sooni sooni hai in Mili and tum bhi chalo from Zameer before Deewaar, Trishul and Kaala Patthar briefly made him the angry-brooding-man-who-won’t-sing again.

But Amitabh had by now evolved into a powerful and multi-faceted actor. So he could become a poet again to sing main pal do pal ka shaayar hoon in Kabhi Kabhie (sung by Mukesh), become the adorable my name is Anthony Gonsalves in Amar Akbar Anthony, pine for his childhood love in Muqaddar ka Sikandar’s tere bina bhi kya jeena, or become a singer again with aplomp in rim jhim gire saawan (Manzil) or chhukar mere man ko (Yaarana).

There was also a brief period when Amitabh sang his songs himself: mere angne mein in Lawaaris and rang barse in Silsila, but there was no doubt that Kishore Kumar was Amitabh Bachchan’s voice; in fact my pick for the Amitabh-Kishore combo would be this song:

— I want to thank, again, Shantanu Bhattacharya, for his corrections and suggestions.

12 thoughts on “He sings for him-2

  1. Just thought I would point out that Main pal do pal ka shayar hoon is Mukesh. not Kishore, as is the Kabhi Kabhie title song. Also Abhimaan had three singers singing for Amitabh – Kishore (Meet na mila), Rafi (Teri bindiya re), and, astonishingly, Manhar (Lute koi man ka nagar).

  2. I realize this is centered around Hindi films, but it somehow feels incomplete without bringing in some legendary pair-ups like S.P Balasubramaniam – Kamal Haasan, TM Soundarrajan – Sivaji Ganesan etc.

  3. Sir, thanks again for this compilation..but I would suggest you include ‘main kabhi kavi na ban jaun’ & ‘mere dushman tu meri dosti ko tarse’ for Dharmendra . Also notable absentees from your line up..Manoj Kumar, Jitendra, Rishi Kapoor, etc. are worthy for another episode perhaps?

  4. I wrote a comment a few days back, it seems to have disappeared into the ether so here I am again!

    Wonderful post Srinivas! I read your part one a second time to remind myself of the songs you covered. I may not agree with all your song choices but certainly you have picked some very memorable ones. There are many hours of good listening in the music you have listed. I have not much followed Sunil Dutt, so rather surprised to see so many good songs lipped by him! Instead of Shashi, perhaps you should have considered Bharat Bhushan? Rafi has sung such good songs for him! And you have left out the Mukherjee brothers who (surprisingly!) have been part of some very good music of that era. And like Kalyan Ghosh has said in his comment above, Jeetu (dont forget Bhupinder on Jeetu!), Manoj Kumar (some nice Mukesh here) and Rishi should not be missed either. I demand another post on the subject!!

  5. I seriously considered Bharat Bhushan, and also Pradeep Kumar. Both have many lovely Rafi songs. And while the brother Joy Mukherjee has a set of wonderful songs (many by O P Nayyar), Biswajit had a lot of OP and also some of the best by Hemant Kumar. So I do indeed believe that another post is needed!

  6. Absolutely brilliant compilation … enjoyed revisiting all the songs on a friday night! I actually replayed “Chalo ek baar phir se…” sung by Mahendra kapoor for Sunil Dutt – by far, my favourite piano-song. And then started to think about other great piano-songs. The other four making up MY Top 5: (2) “Aap ke haseen rukh pe…”: Mohd Rafi – Dharmendra (3) “Khwaab ho tum ya koi haqeeqat ho …”: Kishore Kumar – Dev Anand (4) “Pyaar diwana hota hai …”: Kishore Kumar – Rajesh Khanna and (5) “Koi sone ke dilwala …”: Mohd. Rafi. – Dev Anand. Let me know if any of you can think of one that beats the above five! Too bad that I am not savvy enough to provide you all youtube links …

  7. Yes, please don’t leave out the wonderful pradeep kumar who has lots of beautiful songs picturised on him and sang by the one and only mohd rafi the films include Taj Mahal and Bahu Begum amongst many others, truly mesmerizing !!!!!!

  8. I have a strong feeling that if all songs that were sung by Md Rafi for Sashi Kapoor and Dharmendra are compared with those sang by Kishoreji for them in the 1970s, magic of Md Rafi songs would be undoubtedly superior, in terms of both tune & voice timbre. Why then they allow musicians to shift to Kishoreji?was it commercial preassure or part of the larger conspiracy that they had fallen prey to. Your opinionplease?

  9. sorry kishores ghungroo ki trah has more depth and soa lso pal pal dil ke pass. kishores dream girl has more romantic softness. any day kishoe sasi and dharam were better combos!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s